the william taft vegetarian diner
On Calyer St., between Lorimer and Guernsey, two blocks down from Manhattan Ave., is a tiny commercial space. One side is a laundromat, and the other side has had a few tenants.
When I moved to Greenpoint, that side was occupied by a shop that seemed to only sell fabric softener and motor oil (at least, that’s all that was ever in the window). One of those stores that you look at from the outside and think, “How on earth do they stay in business?”
They were replaced by an Italian sandwich shop called Frangello’s. We were excited when this place opened because Greenpoint needed a good sandwich shop. And they were very, very good - but it took them 20 minutes to make one sandwich, and they were never open. They closed at 3pm on Saturday. Not open on Sunday. Closed by 5pm every weekday. We would walk by there and say, “I’m going home to change and I’ll be back in 15 minutes on my way to the ball game, I’d like to get a sandwich” and they’d reply, “Sorry, we’re closing.” Needless to say, all of these factors is probably why they barely lasted three months.
A few months back, the shuttered space had a sign taped to it, announcing the William Taft Vegetarian Restaurant. We weren’t sure if it was a joke or not. Walking by once to find people inside cleaning, we asked when the place would open and were told April 15. That day came and went, and I just assumed it was another NYC restaurant venture that just never got off the ground.
A few weeks ago, we noticed that the bright red FRANGELLO’S awning had been removed. We hoped that meant progress. And last night, the boyfriend noted that there was a new sign out front. I walked up today to get this shot:
There were people inside painting, who claimed they should be open by the end of the month. Hey guys, here’s a tip: DON’T CLOSE AT 5PM BEFORE ANYONE IS HOME FROM WORK. If they actually are open at times that people want to order food (and the delivery will be key), and the food is any good, the location is excellent and they should do well.
Hey, at least it’s not another bar.






